Skip to main content

Your collaborators can ruin your shared folders

Shared folders (which used to be called collections) in Google Drive (which used to be called Docs) rocks. I preferred the term collections over folders because the metaphor worked better. In the real world you cannot put one document into two separate folders, but in Drive you can. I'll get over it. I'm more concerned with how destructive collaborators could be in shared folders.

Last year I had all of my students submit their work to me in a shared folder. One folder for each assignment. It was great. They had the responsibility of "turning it in," and I could see all of the docs in one place. This is SO much better than having students email you their work, and it keeps everything organized. When I tell people I do this, their first comment is, "don't all students have access to other student work?" My answer is, "Yes, and that's great." Their concern is (A) they might steal other student writing and (B) they might vandalize other student writing. I'm not worried about (A) because I'll recognize it when I'm grading. (B) is not a problem either because the revision history is tracked. Therefore, if someone writes, "Billy smells" all over someone's essay, I can intervene, turn it into the dreaded "learning moment," and revert the document to its original state. 

Last week as I was working with some teachers, transferring files from one Drive account to another using shared folders, I noticed something strange. 

Sam shares a folder with Jim. Sam creates a document in this shared folder. Jim removes that document from the folder (puts it in the trash). Sam loses document. He cannot find it in his Drive list anywhere. He can search for it, but he cannot find it unless he clicks "All Items." 




Unless I'm missing something, I might no longer use shared folders to have my students submit their work, because students could delete other student work, and it would look like they never turned in their assignments. Am I missing something here? 

Some folks in my PLC have recommended that I have students create their own shared folders with me. This is not ideal for me because I always assess student work by assignment, not student, so I would have to click through different folders for each student when I sit down to grade papers. This solution also undermines the POSITIVE aspect of shared folders. I WANT my students to read (and comment) on their peers' writing. 

Susan in my PLC has contacted Google about the issue, and they replied that it's a "known issue." By issue, I wonder if they think it is a problem or a feature. The problem is solved if only the owner of a folder could remove other people's documents from that folder. Or am I missing an unintended consequence of that restriction?


Until then, I'm going to have to think hard about how to move forward next year. Perhaps I can have my students share their docs with the setting "Anyone in the domain with the link can edit this document," then paste that link into a separate form for each assignment. I could then allow my class to view the populated spreadsheet. They would still be able to access other student documents but they wouldn't be able to remove links (papers) from the spreadsheet. 


[UPDATE]


I shared with with some other Google Apps for EDU Certified Trainers and Eric Curts had a great response. 
Kevin,

Using a form to collect the links for the submitted documents is a great idea.  However, you wouldn't have to use a different form for each assignment.  Just make one of the question in the Google Form be "Assignment" and then have that be a "Choose from a list" type question.  You can type in the current list of assignments that can be submitted, and the students can pick the assignment from the drop down list.  What is so nice about this is that you can filter by the assignment when in the spreadsheet view (if you want), and see all of the submissions for one assignment at a time.  You can go back and edit the assignment list in the form whenever you need to, without having to create a new form each time and share that link. And you can delete or hide rows for old assignments that no longer need to be accessed.

I have a few more details in this section of the "Paperless Classroom" Google Doc:

 Thanks, Eric. This may be my new workflow. 


Hank Thiele adds ...

One rule you must establish with your students: assignments "turned in" must be either shared with you, or anyone with the link, or they are not accepted. Otherwise smart students will submit blank or incomplete unshared work - thus buying more time to finish.Not shared = not turned in.

Popular posts from this blog

Assignment #1: Introduce Yourself

As I mentioned in my previous post, the first thing I do in class is have my students write and deliver two minute introductions. Obviously it gives me a sense of their writing and presentation skills, but more importantly it allows me to know who they are. Here's the prompt I give them:
Your first formal assignment is to compose and present a short introduction so I may better get to know you. I'm only looking for a two minute introduction. I would like you to type it out and then read it to the class. Make sure you save your work somewhere because I'm going to ask you to post it in your portfolio (more on that later). I'd like to get a sense of who you are and what your voice is. Not sure what to write? No problem ... here are some ideas to help get you started: What are you passionate about?What are some of your goals for the year? For your life?What is the most important physical object in your life? (take a photo of it and bring it to class)What is your greatest f…

A letter to my students and parents about the 20% Project

Dear Students and Parents of the York School 10th Grade Class,

I hope you all had an adventurous and energizing summer. I wanted to write to introduce myself and let you know a little bit about one of the unusual projects we’ll be taking on this year in English III.

In 2011 we began The 20% Project in English III. This is a major project-based-learning assignment that spans the entire school year and encourages students to pursue a creative interest they would otherwise not experience in our academic program at York.
Before I get into the details of the project, I want to explain why we’re asking students to participate in this activity. For over 20 years a trend in education has been gaining momentum that suggests the role of the teacher ought to shift away from an industrial model where the teacher stands in the front of the classroom to dispense knowledge through lectures, and the students sit to consume the information. Rather than being the “sage on the stage” as some …

It's time. Turn on 2-step Verification in your Google Account

If your Google account happens to be one of the billion Internet passwords The New York Times just reported to have been amassed by a Russian gang, then your docs, your mail, and your puppy photos are in the hands of a ... well ... Russian gang. Unless you have 2-Step Verification turned on.

We have no idea if any of these passwords are actually Google accounts, but really it makes no difference. The password system for proving that you are you is completely broken. Almost all passwords are weak even when websites say they're strong. If your password doesn't look like this ...
8.;=>#qH->8'6Mv  ... it's weak.

If it does look like that, then it's only secure as long as the Russian gang or any other hacker hasn't stolen it.

So far, the best way to protect your accounts is to use 2-Step Verification.

With 2-Step, access to your account requires not only something you know (password), but also something you have (your phone). After you have it turned on, each …